I have decided to put together a top 20 list of Manchester United players to have played for the club in my lifetime. I was born in September 1986 and have followed United since I was about 7 or 8 – so my lifetime for United players is from 1994-2010.
My criteria for this list is based on players I have seen and who have inspired me, along with goals scored and appearances for the club. Growing up, Eric Cantona and David Beckham were my idols, however Ryan Giggs has since gained my respect for obvious reasons. Here is the list:
- Ryan Giggs
- Wayne Rooney
- Eric Cantona
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- David Beckham
- Ruud van Nistelrooy
- Roy Keane
- Rio Ferdinand
- Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
- Peter Schmeichel
- Andy Cole
- Teddy Sheringham
- Nemanja Vidic
- Paul Scholes
- Patrice Evra
- Denis Irwin
- Edwin van der Sar
- Gary Neville
- Jaap Stam
- John O’Shea
Ryan Giggs – Simply the best player to have played for the club. 20 years at the top and a bagful of goals, assists and appearances make him number 1 on my list. He also lives down the road so although he is Welsh, he is a local lad – just listen to him talk!
Wayne Rooney – What a fantastic player, he may be a scouser but because he is so good he is an honourary Manc! He has been at the club for 6 seasons now and has scored a load of goals and is the inspiration and heartbeat of the team. Even when Ronaldo was at the club, Rooney was still adored by more hardcore fans for his work rate and never say die attitude.
Eric Cantona - Eric the King was a legend. From his audacious flicks, his outstanding presence and his range of qualities on the football field, he was a leader all the way. He captained the team and led them to many league and FA Cup victories. Simply magnifique.
Cristiano Ronaldo – From 2003 the player brought in to replace David Beckham, this guy grew stronger and better and peaked in the 2007/08 season scoring 40+ goals in that year. He terrorised defences and won many trophies in 6 seasons with the club. He eventually left for a staggering £80 million in 2009 for Real Madrid but for many years he was held in high regard by me and many others.
David Beckham – The best set-piece taker and crosser of the ball I have ever seen, anywhere. He was fantastic, he led his team and country to many victories, never as club captain but he was inspirational all the same. He was my favourite player at the club after Cantona left and I was devastated when he went to Real Madrid in summer 2003. We didn’t win the league for 3 seasons after he left and I seriously don’t think this was coincidence.
Ruud van Nistelrooy – What a machine – this guy scored bagfuls of goals. In one season he combined with Beckham to score 46 goals in all competitions and 25 in the league. He only won the league with us once, and won the FA Cup and Carling Cup too but he was a great goalscorer and once Beckham left, the crosses stopped and he didn’t score as many. He was still a great player though and inside the box there was no one better.
Roy Keane – Captain fantastic. As the song says, “Keano is a wizard is he wears a magic hat, and when he saw Old Trafford he said I fancy that, he didn’t go to Arsenal or Blackburn cos they’re shite, he came to Man United cos we’re fucking dynamite.” Leader, many trophies, controversial but all round midfield general.
Rio Ferdinand – The best defender I have seen at the club in my lifetime. He leads from the back and now in his 8th season with the club he is England captain and the rock in our defence. He has won many trophies and often has centre forwards in his back pocket. A calming influence on the defence and a true red.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer – 1999, Nou Camp – say no more. What a fantastic servant for the club. Happy to be on the bench and make an impact from there. He scored a lot of goals and played many games in 10 seasons with United before finally retiring due to injuries. He is now reserve team manager and still a huge influence at the club developing talent.
Peter Schmeichel – The best goalkeeper I have ever seen play. Led from the back, scored a few goals and played so many games for the club it was hard to replace him. A commanding presence and great team player, Schmeichel was inspirational and the best shot stopper in the league/Europe for a good 7 or 8 years.
Andy Cole – Scored a lot of goals and was part of the treble winning team and fantastic partnership with Dwight Yorke. He was a great player and “Goal King Cole” will always be a big part of my memory of United in the 90s. His lob over Ian Walker that got us the title in 1999 will be in my mind forever.
Teddy Sheringham – Lots of goals, a cult hero and got the equaliser in the Nou Camp in 99. His goals and personality helped to fill the gap left by Eric Cantona after his departure in 1997. Sheringham stayed for 4 years and in his final season (00/01) he was top scorer and was replaced by van Nistelrooy, leaving for a second spell at Spurs.
Nemanja Vidic – A rock at the back for the last 4 years and forming a great partnership with Rio Ferdinand he is the Steve Bruce figure of my generation. He scores goals and is a commanding presence at the back. All round cult hero and work horse.
Paul Scholes – An un-sung hero, he has developed from a goal-scoring midfielder to a deep lying playmaker. He has made countless appearances and scored magnificent goals. Formed a great partnership with Roy Keane and then Michael Carrick but has lost his first team status in the last year or so. His hard tackling and scoring abilities are loved among fans and he will forever be remembered as a true red.
Patrice Evra – the best left back I have ever witnessed playing. His touch and reading of the game are phenomenal, his passing and tackling are immense and he even captains the team in the absence of others. Patrice has been no.1 left back for 5 years now and there is no one better in terms of linking defence, with midfield and attack.
Denis Irwin – He was a legend at the club and a fantastic servant. Could play at right or left back and was a hard tackling, penalty-taking leader. He was inspirational and throughout the 1990s he was the best full back in the league. He didn’t do anything special but worked hard and was consistent.
Edwin van der Sar – Who could possibly replace Peter Schmeichel? Not Bosnich, not Van der Gouw, not Taibi, not Barthez, not Carroll, not Howard – but Edwin van der Sar. He has been the best keeper at the club since the Great Dane left in 1999. Joining from Fulham in 2005, he has won many trophies with the club and at the age of 39 is showing no signs of decline. Got the clean sheet record last season for most consecutive clean sheets. A fantastic keeper and looks after himself.
Gary Neville – Has been first choice right back since 1995 and has provided many assists down the years. Now club captain but blighted by injuries he is one of the longest serving players at the club. Came through the Golden generation at Old Trafford in 1994 and has won many trophies and won many tackles. A hard working, inspirational player. Not everyone’s cup of tea but held in high regard at Old Trafford – a cult hero and red through and through.
Jaap Stam – Only at the club for 3 seasons but he made a massive impact on the United defence. Formed a great partnership with Ronny Johnsen and won many trophies with the club. Fergie admitted he made a mistake in selling him in 2001 but while he was with the club he was a fantastic servant and leader.
John O’Shea – Now in his 8th full season with the club, the solid dependable, versatile John O’Shea is a cult hero at Old Trafford. He is good going forward and can play in any position across the defence and even in goal! One of the best full backs at United and will be there for the next 5 years no doubt.